Thursday, January 8, 2015

I Stand with Charlie Hebdo (among other thoughts)

In the wake of the disgusting and senseless deaths yesterday at Charlie Hebdo, the message sent loud and clear is that the barbarism and fear that characterized 2014 will extend seamlessly into 2015.  This all started because a bunch of cartoonists did the daring act of drawing the Prophet Mohammed (yes that was their crime).  I don’t see why in the 21st century (or really any century), drawing Mohammed is an act worthy of death.  These terrorists should take a page from the most popular religious leader of late; Pope Francis.  The Pope has sent a message of acceptance, tolerance, and peace rather than the traditional Catholic decrees of intolerance and hate and in return has become beloved.  He has taken great steps to softening the Catholic Church and has displayed great kindness to the poor, the downtrodden, and the underdog with his attacks on our out of control capitalist system and his famous statement “of who am I to judge”.  Ergo, this man has brought people like me, a strict Jewish agonist/atheist to his side along with people like Bill Maher (an even stricter atheist).  This guy is the way to lead a religion into the 21st century.  Killing people over crude cartoon images of your Prophet isn’t going to make much headway. 

In my mind, Islam is in need of a reformation akin to what happened to Christianity in the 1500’s.  The religion is about 1400 years old and is in need of a Martin Luther to step up and nail a set of 95 Thesis to the wall of a Mosque.  Hell I would settle for a Vatican II or something of the sort to help modernize parts of the religion (yes I do realize that Islam isn’t as centralized as the Catholic Church but still a meeting of high clerics couldn’t hurt).  It’s just infuriating to continually hear about people living in fear or dying for what they have drawn or who they have insulted.  Salmon Rushdie is still on the list of Al Qaeda’s most wanted and all he did was write a book (on Friday he will be on Real Time with Bill Maher so we know that will be a great show).


But in reality, what more is there to say that hasn’t already been said?  This topic of people dying because they dared “insult the Prophet Mohammed” has become so much a part of our cultural dialogue that it is almost expected when somebody draws their pen to paper.  I’ve seen plenty of Anti-Semetic drawings and writings but today you’ll just see the JDL rather than cold blooded assassins.  I didn’t see a gang of militant Jews gunning down the producers and actors of the Death of Kilnghoffer over the fall.  You fight art with art, not with bullets and death threats.  What does that do?  How does that help what Jon Stewart would call “Team Civilization”?  We as a civilization need to move past the need to threaten people, especially comedians and satirists, with death because they discussed a sacred item or hold a dissenting opinion.  There are no sacred or untouchable items in society today and that’s fine.  Everything is up for mockery and I wouldn’t have it any other way.  Hopefully, we can get some of the crazies on board or else who knows anymore.  Who knows?

No comments:

Post a Comment